Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Tragedy?

When asked who i thought was the most popular literary author in the history of mankind was (excluding the Bible) i though about it for a while, and responded Shakespear. Now i think about the amazing works that Shakespear put forth and 3 came to mind. Romeo and Juliet, Hamlet, and Macbeth. Now all three of these works are tragedy's. Stories in which nearly every one of the major charecters die, whether by violence, suicide, old age, murder, or accident almost all of them die. This revealation seems to me to be rather telling about the human condition. That our favorite "reflections of reality" are stories where death, sadness, and suffering are the main ideas behind the stories. Then i thought more about these "tragedy's", and i have come to the conclusion that they are not tragedy's. Rather they are an accurate reflection of reality, in that the greater evil is always defeated, but in the process of A. indentifying the evil, and B. defeating it that some people will be lost. In each one of Shakespear's "tragedy's" a greater evil is defeated. For example, Romeo and Juliet, in the story even though the list of dead is long the underlying problem of the Capulet's and Montegue's feud is ended because of the "tragedy". Hamlet, the issue of succession of the throne is dealt with and the usurper is killed. Macbeth is differant because of the point of view of the story. However the usurper is killed and justice is served. So my question is this. Are ideals and morals more important than the people that die to uphold them? Because if they are then these stories are tragedies but if they are not then these stories are stories of reality, because i promise that good never comes free and to defeat evil a price must be paid.

2 comments:

Josh Poshy Pudding n Pie said...

I understand what you are saying and it is completely true.
Since this is a comment and will not be seen by many I can be honest here.

That blog was directed at people that cheat and get away with it and then they leave school and do other bad things.
My conversation with Lauren which was referenced in my first line was that the same people that habitually cheat are also slutty and partiers but those are stereotypes still.
I imagine you know who I am referencing in the class. So as for your average Joe the plumbers like you and I, we get the short stick for doing what is right while they are rewarded for doing everything wrong.

The reason your response was dead on was the use of Bible verses and when you talked about faith being dead. To claim to be a Christian puts you on that higher standard before God and also before people so you do no harm the image of God. So for those people who habitually do what is wrong, their faith is dead but I would say never existed.

That was an excellent response Mr. Bob.
I am sorry to hear that your beloved McCain has fallen yet his farewell speech was beautiful even though his crowd was rowty.

Norman said...

bro, its spelled Shakespeare. SHAKESPREARE!!!! but very, very good thoughts man